← Back to perspectives
/Intellicon FDE Team

Want to Know How Much Switching Models Could Save? Give the Old and New Models the Same Work

Compiling supplier quotes and assessing special payment terms should not be lumped together into a single average. Group tasks by type, use the same data, instructions, and acceptance criteria, then compare the cost and staff time needed to meet those standards.

AIEgentWrX人機協作導入
Want to Know How Much Switching Models Could Save? Give the Old and New Models the Same Work

The sales team wants to try a new model to compile quotes. IT has reviewed the test scores and thinks it is worth a trial. But before approving the switch, managers also need to account for the time employees spend checking part numbers, correcting terms, and redoing work after failed attempts. If the model produces more polished answers but employees need more time to deliver the finished work, what has the upgrade actually saved?

The FDE team at Intellicon Solutions believes that evaluating an upgrade means comparing the total money and time needed to produce work that meets requirements, rather than looking at a single successful result. Teams first need to define what makes an output acceptable, then record the cost of each attempt and the time employees spend revising or redoing the work. Only then can they determine which tasks justify switching models and which should stay as they are.

Do Higher Test Scores Mean Lower Costs and Less Time Spent?

According to a model report published by TechOrange, coding tests released by Anthropic showed that increasing reasoning effort, which controls how much reasoning the model performs, raised the cost per task. However, the highest reasoning setting did not produce the highest score. The report also cited advice from VentureBeat: businesses should compare models using problems they encounter in real work. Beyond model costs, they should account for spending on failed attempts, human review time, and regressions where changes cause previously working functionality to fail.

These findings come from specific coding tests. The original article did not provide results from real-world trials in Taiwan’s manufacturing or traditional industries, so they should not be used to estimate how much your company could save. We recommend first choosing a task to improve, such as compiling procurement quote comparisons. Ask the procurement manager which errors currently take the most time to resolve, then have IT arrange comparative tests. Do not replace every model first and only then look for examples that prove the change was worthwhile.

Define What Counts as Acceptable, Then Give Both Models the Same Work

Employees responsible for the business process should work with IT to select tasks from their actual work. Include both routine cases and cases that have frequently failed in the past, and compare results separately by task type. Compiling supplier quotes and assessing special payment terms, for example, have different output requirements. Combining them into a single average makes it difficult to decide which tasks would benefit from a model change.

For procurement quote comparisons, the team could agree that part numbers and currencies must be correct, delivery lead times and payment terms must include source references, and incomplete terms must be flagged as items requiring clarification. These are suggested acceptance criteria, not an actual customer case. Procurement staff must still verify the content, and supplier selection and purchase approvals should follow existing sign-off procedures.

During testing, the current model and the new model under evaluation should use the same data, task instructions, and acceptance criteria, with each model’s settings recorded. If you change the documents, rewrite the instructions, and increase reasoning effort at the same time, even better results will not tell you which adjustment made the difference. If the instructions need improvement, run a separate round of comparisons rather than combining results produced under different test conditions.

Before testing begins, the employees responsible for the process should identify which errors are unacceptable, and the project lead should define when further attempts must stop. This prevents standards from being relaxed after the answers have been seen. Keep cases that remain incomplete or exceed the time limit in the evaluation; do not remove them simply because they failed to produce a deliverable.

Include Failed Attempts and Manual Revisions to Find the Real Savings

Teams should also create an evaluation sheet to record whether each output meets the requirements, the model cost of every attempt, and the time employees spend reviewing and revising it. If a revision introduces errors into parts that were previously correct, record what went wrong and how long it took to fix. Looking only at the final accepted version hides the effort required to get there.

For comparison, add up all model costs and the cost of human review and revisions for tasks of the same type, then divide by the number of accepted outputs. This provides a reference cost per accepted output. Include the money and staff effort spent on failed cases in the total, and separately list the number of incomplete cases and the reasons for failure. If none of the outputs in a batch meets the requirements, record the batch as unsuccessful rather than calculating a cost per accepted output. If staff time is converted into a monetary cost, use a consistent estimation method across the company rather than allowing each department to choose whichever method makes its results look best.

Keep the actual staff hours alongside the cost estimates. A reduction in estimated labor costs does not necessarily reduce the company’s cash spending in the current period. Conversely, if the new model can complete work the current model cannot, but requires more money or time, managers need to assess whether that additional output justifies the expense. Improved capability should not automatically be reported as cost savings.

EgentWrX lets users switch models for each message, allowing teams to choose a model based on task difficulty. Scoring test results and tracking staff time remain the team’s responsibility, using the standards described above. We recommend switching models first for tasks that meet quality requirements and demonstrably require less overall spending and staff time. If test results are inconsistent or there is not yet enough evidence to support a switch, keep the current setup and run additional tests.

If the Budget Runs Out Before Results Meet Requirements, Investigate Before Spending More

Before comparisons begin, the project lead should set a trial spending limit and separately agree on how much time employees may spend reviewing outputs. EgentWrX supports budgets at the tenant, department, member, and AI Agent levels, but usage is only blocked when “Block” is selected under “Trigger Action.” Teams can therefore set limits for the departments or AI Agent participating in the trial to control platform usage, while recording time spent on revisions or rework separately.

If the budget is exhausted without enough acceptable outputs, review the failure records first. Check whether the model lacked necessary information, whether the assigned task was too broad, or whether employees kept spending time correcting the same errors. Once the cause is clear, decide whether to narrow the scope, use another model, or submit a justified request for additional budget. Do not simply raise the limit because testing is unfinished.

At the next upgrade discussion, ask the employees responsible for the process and IT to bring the same set of records showing which tasks met the requirements, the total spending and staff hours, and which cases remain incomplete. With this evidence, managers can approve model changes for specific tasks and explain why the spending is justified on a firmer basis than a successful demonstration alone.

FAQ

What should we record first when assessing whether a model upgrade saves money?

For each case, record whether the output meets the requirements, the model cost of every attempt, and the time spent on human review and revisions. Keep failed and incomplete cases in the records, then compare results separately by task type. If staff hours are converted into costs, use a consistent estimation method across the company.

Do lower model costs prove that an upgrade saves money?

No. You also need to confirm that comparable tasks consistently meet the acceptance criteria and that employees are not spending more time checking and revising the results. List model costs and staff hours separately before comparing the overall cost, rather than assuming that lower model costs make the entire task cheaper.

If test results are better, should every AI Agent switch models?

Not necessarily. Start with tasks that meet the requirements in actual testing and demonstrably require less overall spending and staff time. Leave the rest unchanged for now. If the new model can do work that was previously impossible but costs more, assess separately whether the output justifies the expense. Greater capability does not, by itself, mean money has been saved.

What should we do if the trial budget runs out before we have enough results?

Pause the trial and investigate the failures rather than immediately raising the limit. Ask the team to compile the incomplete cases and determine whether the problem is insufficient data, an overly broad scope, or too much time spent on revisions. Then propose adjustments and explain why additional budget is needed so managers can decide whether to continue.

References

30 minutes to map out which work to hand to AI first

Want every employee to have their own AI teammate?

A consultant will be in touch shortly.

ISO/IEC 27001:2022 Certified ISMS