When evaluating an AI response, should it pass if it mentions the right solution but spends most of its time teaching employees to continue using the wrong approach? A study featured on the Hugging Face Blog illustrates this problem with a cupcake: a user sees frosting sliding off the cake and asks how to thicken it, when the real problem is that the cake is still too hot. Even if the response mentions letting the cake cool first, users may keep working on the wrong thing if most of the advice still focuses on adjusting the frosting.
At Intellicon Solutions, we believe that business acceptance testing should look beyond whether a response mentions the right method. It should also assess whether employees can get the job done by following its main recommendations. Business teams should therefore define acceptable approaches first, then work with IT to review actual responses. Fluent writing and the presence of expected keywords are not enough to justify a pass.
Why Is Mentioning a Solution Not Enough to Count as Correct?
The research team released XYBench, a benchmark of 8,115 questions designed to test whether models can identify flaws in users’ thinking and help solve the underlying problem. In the main evaluation, five models often offered useful solutions but still focused their responses on the users’ original, misguided approaches. Other experiments also found that models performed better at selecting good advice from existing answers than at writing responses that addressed users’ actual needs. The researchers therefore scored responses separately on whether they offered a solution, what they primarily advised the user to do, and whether they discouraged the user from pursuing the wrong approach.
Businesses can draw on this scoring method, but should not use the study’s results alone to determine whether a model is suitable for their needs. The study focused on English-language how-to questions, allowed each model only one response per question, and provided neither results from Taiwanese businesses nor tests of performance across multiple follow-up exchanges. Start with questions drawn from your own work scenarios, have the model answer them directly, and ask reviewers familiar with the business to assess each of the following:
- Does the response offer a method that can solve the problem? The response should propose a way to address the actual need and explain when it applies. Merely mentioning relevant terms should not earn credit.
- Will the main recommendations help employees do the job correctly? Reviewers should examine what the response recommends first, how it sequences the steps, and what takes up most of the text. Employees should be guided toward the right priorities without having to read to the end to find a critical reminder.
- Is there evidence to support challenging the user’s assumptions? If the available information is sufficient to show that the original approach will not work, the response should explain why. If the evidence is insufficient, it should ask follow-up questions rather than assume the user has asked the wrong question.
Keep the results for each assessment criterion, along with the exact wording that supports each judgment, rather than rushing to combine them into an overall score. This allows the project team to distinguish between a model that does not know how to solve the problem and one that knows the solution but fails to put the right actions first.
Preserve How Employees Originally Asked the Question and Why It Took Them in the Wrong Direction
If the project team rewrites every question into a clear, correct requirement before giving it to the model, the test will not reveal whether the model can detect problems in the original wording. Ask business teams to compile actual records of cases where employees asked questions that led in the wrong direction. For each case, preserve the original question, the background information available at the time, the intended outcome, the mistaken assumption, and acceptable ways to proceed.
Consider a hypothetical procurement scenario: an employee asks for quotations to be sorted by unit price, but actually wants to compare the cost of purchasing options that meet the requirements. If the quotations already show different pack quantities, an acceptable response should first clarify the pricing basis before comparing suppliers’ quotes. If packaging information is missing, it should ask for it rather than declare one supplier cheaper.
When preparing test cases, keep the answer guidance for reviewers separate from the information given to the model. Otherwise, the question may already reveal the true objective, creating the false impression that the model identified the problem itself. Also retain cases with valid premises that can be answered directly, so the model does not learn to challenge every user question simply to meet the scoring criteria.
Before testing, business managers should confirm when the model may offer advice directly, when it must ask follow-up questions, and which decisions still require human approval. For example, an AI Agent can help compare purchasing options, but changes to purchasing terms or decisions to place an order should still go to an authorized approver under company procedures.
Turn Recurring Errors into Skills, Then Test with New Cases
If reviewers repeatedly find the same errors, write specific rules for correcting them rather than simply reminding the model to understand the user. For example, confirm specifications and pricing units before comparing prices; when information is insufficient, identify the missing details that could affect the comparison; and when the original approach cannot achieve the objective, explain why before proposing viable alternatives.
In EgentWrX, teams can organize these established practices into Skills for an AI Agent to apply in appropriate situations. Employees can also explicitly select a Skill during a conversation. Skills let teams store and apply these rules for assessing problems, but they do not guarantee that a model will detect every mistaken assumption. Skills created by employees must also be reviewed and approved in the admin console before they can be used company-wide.
After updating a Skill, run acceptance tests again using cases that were not used to write it. Keep the responses from before and after the change so the project team can compile scorecards and compare results case by case. Pay particular attention to whether questions that previously could be answered directly now trigger unnecessary follow-up questions. If the model merely challenges users more often without offering more appropriate next steps, the change should not count as a successful improvement.
When Choosing Models, Compare the Responses They Actually Write
Multiple-choice tests can show whether a model recognizes a good answer, but employees need it to produce useful advice on demand. IT should therefore give each candidate model the same questions, background information, prompts, and Skill settings. Start a separate conversation for every test to prevent earlier answers from influencing later results.
EgentWrX supports switching models for each message, allowing teams to collect responses from different models on the same platform. Before comparing them, hide the model names and have business reviewers assess the full responses against the same criteria. When reviewers disagree, identify the disputed passages and discuss them in light of business rules, rather than deciding which response is better based on its length or the model’s reputation.
If the actual workflow allows follow-up questions, arrange separate multi-turn tests to see whether the model adjusts its advice after receiving additional information. Record those results separately from the single-turn tests. For the next acceptance review meeting, prepare the original wording of a question, an acceptable approach, and the model’s response. Ask business managers to confirm: if an employee follows this response, what will they do first? Will that action actually help achieve the work objective?
FAQ
Isn’t it enough for the response to mention the right method?
No. Reviewers also need to confirm whether following the main recommendations will help employees solve the underlying problem. If the correct method appears only at the end while the rest of the response explains in detail how to continue with the wrong approach, mark the criterion “Will the main recommendations help employees do the job correctly?” as a fail. Retain the exact wording for comparison when making revisions.
Can AI pass if it asks follow-up questions when information is missing?
Yes, but the questions must help determine what to do next. In each acceptance test case, specify what information is missing and which user answers would change the recommendation. Then check whether the model asks for the critical information, rather than repeatedly requesting more background.
Can we rely solely on another model to score the responses?
No. Disputed responses still need to be reviewed by someone familiar with the business. In the study, automated judges and human reviewers did not always agree on the main focus of a response. Businesses can use a model to help with preliminary review, but the project owner should still confirm the acceptance criteria and pass-or-fail decisions.
References
- XYBench: Helping with the problem behind the question — Hugging Face Blog. The research team introduces the benchmark, the gap between generating responses and selecting answers, and the evaluation methods and limitations.



